• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • NEWS:
  • SatNews
  • SatMagazine
  • MilSatMagazine
  • SmallSat News
  • |     EVENTS:
  • SmallSat Symposium
  • Satellite Innovation

SatNews

  • HOME
  • Magazines
  • Events
  • Perspectives
  • Industry Calendar
    • IN PERSON
    • VIRTUAL
  • Subscribe

Trial Date Set For The SES + Intelsat Legal Dispute

December 7, 2020

Civil Courts building with stone Greek flutted columns and ornate design st louis missouri downtown city

Intelsat’s bankruptcy court on December 3 said the dispute between SES Americom and Intelsat would go to trial next June — the news coincides with a 126-page filing to Intelsat’s court from SES that pulls no punches in its claims.

At the heart of the legal dispute between SES and Intelsat is an argument over Intelsat’s handling of an alleged 50-50 agreed division within the C-Band Alliance (CBA) and how the FCC ‘incentive’ payments over the reallocation of both satellite operators’ C-band frequencies would be allocated. SES is claiming $1.8 billion from Intelsat.

The FCC-organized auction over the sale of the spectrum is now occurring.

The SES vs Intelsat legal action kicked off with a July 14 claim lodged by SES where SES claimed damages and which included alleged breaches of contract, fiduciary duties and unjust enrichment. Intelsat firmly rejected the claim and, in October, added in its own allegations that SES had “improperly shared” a confidential report with the FCC and that the SES claims are without merit.

SES responded on December 4 and described its action against Intelsat as being “about corporate desperation, greed, and dishonesty… Saddled with crippling debt and facing bankruptcy, Intelsat betrayed its faithful contractual partner in a brazen attempt to steal approximately $450 million. This case will hold Intelsat accountable for its unlawful and bad faith conduct”.

The SES filing to the court explains that for 16 months,the pair worked closely together and with a 50-50 agreement – SES claims – firmly in place. SES supports its claim with “proofs” and a slew of documents and describes how the agreement was “repudiated” and renegade upon by Intelsat. “The 50-50 split was the cornerstone of the Agreement, with SES and Intelsat sharing control over the CBA and the vast majority of its proceeds equally, and the remaining proceeds going to the two other satellite operators in the CBA and covering the costs of the CBA. Without the 50-50 split, SES would not have entered into the Agreement,” stated the SES document.

The court filing adds that even following the FCC’s decision to hold its own auction, the two parties continued to work together for many months and reaffirmed the 50-50 split in words and conduct. Numerous documents were jointly filed to the FCC, some two dozen press releases issued, FCC officials met, joint technical work undertaken, and the commencement of updating the 50-50 Agreement started while retaining the 50-50 split.

The SES document explains how there was a celebratory dinner between Intelsat’s CEO Stephen Spengler and SES’s CEO Steve Collar following the FCC decision. But then, SES alleges, Intelsat reversed course. “At that critical time, Intelsat was facing severe financial distress, including a crippling amount of debt that exceeded $15 billion, and spiralling toward bankruptcy. The temptation to steal hundreds of millions of dollars from SES proved too great,” stated the filing.

The document continues in similar vein, describing Spengler “contritely” making a telephone call to Collar at 3:00 a.m. (EST) one morning and saying he had “a problem” and that the Agreement was no longer binding. “Mr. Collar was shocked. Intelsat’s position was a sham and pretext. Not only was it contrary to the parties’ course of performance under the Agreement, but also the written terms of the Agreement itself.”

“SES now seeks to recover for the massive harm that Intelsat’s breach will cause and for Intelsat’s intentional, wanton, and bad faith conduct. SES’s claims should be allowed in full, and Intelsat’s claim objection and motion for equitable subordination should be dismissed,” continued the SES filing.

The key dates in the action now are:

  • February 7: The parties must make pre-trial disclosures
  • January 11: Third-party documents discovery
  • March 19: Expert testimony disclosed
  • April 30: All fact discovery completed
  • May 14: Rebuttals disclosed
  • May 28: Motions filed
  • June 7: Arguments narrowed, by agreement
  • June 14: Exhibits declared, and witnesses filed
  • June 28: Trial date, if not settled prior

Filed Under: Analysis / Reports, Business Moves

Primary Sidebar

Most Read Stories

  • UPDATE 3: A Successful 'Another One Leaves The Crust' Launch Completed By Rocket Lab
  • SpaceX Launches The NROL-108 Mission For The NRO From Kennedy Space Center
  • OneWeb Gathers Additional Funding, Bringing Total To $1.4 Billion + Reduces Size Of Their Constellation
  • NASA's Landsat-9 USSF Developed ESPA EFS Passes Design Status Review 3
  • Airbus To Build Two OneSat Satellites For Intelsat

About Satnews

  • Contacts
  • History

Archives

  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020

Secondary Sidebar

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy
We Love Our Advertisers.
And you will too!

Please disable your adblock browser plugin to continue...

We promise to keep it unobtrusive.
We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time.
Invalid email address
Thanks for subscribing! Please check your email for further instructions.
x
Sign up Now (For Free)
Access daily or weekly satellite news updates covering all aspects of the commercial and military satellite industry.
Invalid email address
Notify Me Regarding ( At least one ):
We value your privacy and will not sell or share your email or other information with any other company. You may also unsubscribe at anytime.

Click Here to see our full privacy policy.
Thanks for subscribing!